Kilmer has his moments but it felt a bit too hammy in comparison. Ive always liked kurt russell and one of my favorite movies is the 1982 horror classic the thing. So this thread is more of a statement of how in my opinion wyatt earp is the better film to tombstone on every level. The decision was split among movie critics and audiences. Tombstone and wyatt earp were two bigbudget western biopics released within six months of each other, but which movie is the best. Why tombstone and wyatt earp were released six months apart music. Tombstone 1993 full movie lets join, full episode here.
Billy bob thornton completely adlibbed his scene stealing. I was arguing with my friend yesterday and he kept trying to tell me how the kurt russel wyatt earp tombstone had better acting and was better than kevin costners earp i looked at. I like costner as an actor, but he just cant keep it straight. Every so often, rival hollywood studios make films which cover similar themes or events and release them in cinemas to do battle at the box office. All of this being said, i think tombstone was the better entertaining film, while we was more interesting from a learning experience.
For more on the making of the movie, see the making of tombstone. Its a rambling, unfocused biography of wyatt earp kevin costner, starting when hes a kid and following his development from an awkward wouldbe lawyer into a slick gunslinger. First, i think kevin costner is a better actor than kurt russell. The three earp brothers who first arrived arrived to tombstone in late 1879 didnt include morgan unlike in the tombstone movie. The one with kurt russel or the one with kevin costner. He, and his two brothers with their families move to tombstone to make their fortunes. I have read nothing to make me think wyatt earp was anything like that. Glaring flaws aside, i will always enjoy tom sizemores performance as bat masterson. Kurt russell als wyatt earp in tombstone, 1993 dekode kurt russell as wyatt earp in tombstone. Good shot for details of his costume and gunleather. Costner was much, much better in open range which is overlooked way too much. Corral but it is, nonetheless, a very entertaining film.
He worked in a wide variety of trades throughout his life and took part in the famous gunfight at the o. Unlike other adaptations of the same subject namely, kurt russells earp in tombstone, this film deals with the famous gunfight as merely a step in earp s life. Tombstone is streets better than wyatt earp, that was made at the same time. After moving to tombstone, arizona, he got into a feud, which ended in a gunfight at the o. Unlike tombstone, wyatt earp did not benefit from positive word of mouth.
Kevin costners wyatt earp came out 20 years ago today, just six months after tombstone and hollywood was barely big enough. Costner made a visit to the actual tombstone, arizona way before filming ever started. Rather, the film focuses on the man behind the legend. Though wyatt earp had some admirable aspirations, it was ultimately hampered by hammy histrionics and a cluttered plot.
Tombstone was in a race to theaters against kevin costners wyatt earp, which came out six months later. The 10 best movies about wyatt earp and doc holliday. Corral, during which lawmen killed three outlaw cochise county cowboys. Costner was wooden, bored, pissed off or half asleep. Which had the better performances tombstone or wyatt earp.
Wyatt berry stapp earp march 19, 1848 january, 1929 was an old west lawman and gambler in cochise county, arizona territory, and a deputy marshal in tombstone. Wyatt earp is good, as is hour of the gun, but tombstone is the best, in my opinion. Its not as historically accurate as wyatt earp, but is the most exciting, and has better actors in the roles. Critics were harsh, with roger ebert stating that wyatt earp plays as if they took tombstone and pumped it full of hot. Which of these three films on wyatt earp and the o. A 30second gunfight at the ok corral in 1881 propelled sometimelawman wyatt earp to legendary status as one of the wests toughest badges, but it wasnt until the early days of the clinton administration that two films both took aim at each other at high noon to tell the modern version of his story. The early 1990s saw a battle between two bigbudget takes on earp s life. He meets his brothers there, as well as his old friend doc holliday. Tombstone premiered in movie theaters six months before costner and kasdans version, wyatt earp, on december 24, 1993, in wide release throughout the united states. Instead james and his wife bessie arrived with wyatt and virgil. The authenticity that sinks in while viewing wyatt earp may have the more discerning movie goer realizing earp is actually better than the more immediately entertaining tombstone which seemed to be more widely viewed and appreciated after similar release periods. Wyatt earp comes a bit closer to where that was coming from because the guy is not really as heroic as the way kurt russell played him in tombstone. Wyatt earp 1994 fullhd movies, wyatt earp 1994 fullhd movies, wyatt earp 1994 fullhd movies. Those who strongly preferred tombstone and those who strongly maintained that wyatt earp was the superior product.
It involves many of the same characters and much of the same story, but little of the tension and drama. Hes well known now from his lawman days, and thats mostly from movies, and the o. Wyatt earp kurt russell and his brothers, morgan bill paxton and virgil sam elliott, have left their gunslinger ways behind them to settle down and start a business in the town of tombstone. Why tombstone and wyatt earp were released six months. Kurt russell is perfectly cast in the lead role, as is val kilmer in the role as doc holiday. Kurt russell as wyatt earp in tombstone this movie is a classic just watched it again with my son last night. Save this entry was posted in 55 greatest westerns and tagged charlton heston, kurt russell, outlaw gangs, town taming, val kilmer, wyatt earp on august 2, 20 by nicholas chennault.
Tombstone movie insider info, fun quotes, trailer, real. This early wyatt earp movie, based on stuart lake s book frontier marshall, presents a very romanticized version of the gunfight at the o. Tombstone was the best movie, and had the best actors. After success cleaning up dodge city, wyatt earp moves to tombstone, arizona, and wishes to get rich in obscurity. This movie is much admired even by nonwestern fans especially for its portrayal of the friendship between earp kurt russell and holliday. Morgan and their other brother warren, arrived the middle of 1880. The film follows the life of wyatt earp, from his boyhood, through the fight at the o. Val kilmer tombstone quotes tombstone 1993 tombstone movie doc holliday tombstone ill be your huckleberry movie stars movie tv wyatt earp val kilmer as doc holliday in the movie tombstone. On the other hand, when you tune into a movie about earp, you want to see a detailed account of the shoot out at the ok corral, and wyatt earp kind of passed through the clantonmclaury confrontations with the earps while tombstone presented not only detail, but much of it was pretty accurate by hollywood standards not perfect, but.
But for younger viewers, a better introduction to the wyatt earp legend is john fords my darling clementine 1946. Wyatt earp plays as if they took tombstone and pumped it full of hot air. Wyatt earp was a frontiersman, marshal and gambler. Although you probably wouldnt want to write a collegelevel history paper based on the facts in this movie either. I recently saw a program on history i think it was anyway, it says that between tombstone, wyatt earp and the others, tombstone is the closest to actual history. Wyatt earp was another one of costners movies, like the untouchables, where he starts with a true event, then screws it up. Behind the scenes of a classic modern western, by john farkis 2018. After watching tombstone, i wanted to know more about wyatt and doc. Then, mere months later, wyatt earp rode into movie theaters throughout north america. Tombstone is a part of pop culture, not sure anyone quotes lines from wyatt earp. Wyatt earp 18481929 was a wild west frontiersmen best known for his participation in a notorious gunfight at the o.